Aaron Rodgers vs Peyton Manning(2012)

ECPackers · Joined: 24 Oct 2010 Posts: 652

how about either?

you could change out rodgers, manning, and brady right now, on any of those 3 teams, and all would have similar success IMO.
_________________
GREEN BAY PACKERS
JARRET BUSH IS MY BOY!
Brewers
Bucks
Badgers

rwankstat25 · Joined: 20 Dec 2010 Posts: 47

jrry32, You're posts in this thread are pointless and they don't belong here

tonyto, I barely go on this site, but every time I do, you're talking about Tom Brady. Give it a rest already. This has nothing to do with Tom Brady, but I guess you can't read, so I'll entertain you. Aaron Rodgers is better than Tom Brady.

texans, You're blind if you think Peyton is having the better season. Aaron Rodgers is having the best season this year. If he didn't absolutely destroy the league last year, this wouldn't even be a question. He's slightly less impressive than he was last year, but he's still not far off the numbers he put up. Peyton's neck injury is irrelevant...technically, so are the arguments for Rodgers (o-line, receivers, etc). It comes down to who is the better player? Who offers more? Its Aaron Rodgers.

If you can combat Rodgers arguments about chemistry and blah blah blah, then I'll combat the neck injury argument with this: If Rodgers missed all of last year with the same neck injury like Manning did, and he came back this year playing the way he is, most of America and anyone with football knowledge would know Rodgers is playing better.

p.s. get Tom Brady out of here. He doesn't belong.

OakRaiders3828 · Joined: 18 Aug 2007 Posts: 9157 Location: Pennsylvania

rwankstat25 · Joined: 20 Dec 2010 Posts: 47

I only took shots at texans for the reason because just downright dumb arguments were made and defended. Its not about who is most impressive. tonyto is just like a plague on some of these threads so its annoying. Clearly the top two QB's this year are Rodgers and Manning. Manning is playing unbelievably. Rodgers is playing better. The main reason people say Manning is just because of his story. Its irrelevant, thats all.

Papa-Pwn · Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 4:38 pm Post subject:

Pugger · Joined: 01 May 2010 Posts: 4350 Location: N. Fort Myers, FL

All I know is I'll take Rodgers over Peyton and every other QB in the league without hesitation.
_________________

OakRaiders3828 · Joined: 18 Aug 2007 Posts: 9157 Location: Pennsylvania

Russell2Bailey · Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 8:48 pm Post subject:

Dalton · Joined: 16 Mar 2010 Posts: 1636 Location: Illinois

Ketchup · Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 9:07 pm Post subject:

Rich7sena · Joined: 12 Sep 2009 Posts: 1902

I've thought Rodgers is the best QB in the league since 2009.

Russell2Bailey · Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 9:43 pm Post subject:

crabbylion · Joined: 12 Nov 2012 Posts: 8 Location: Saint Petersburg, FL

Good poll you got going on here. For this season AND all time Manning gets my vote. He's in a whole new environment (not to mention the thinner Denver air.) A repaired neck, new system, lesser quality RBs, need I say more. No knocking Rogers, but Peyton's story is undeniable.
_________________
Crabby Lion Sports and More is your source for sports collectibles, apparel, and footwear. Savings and service is what we do!

Packerfaninmn · Joined: 03 Jul 2007 Posts: 6800

AtariB20 · Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2012 12:28 am Post subject:

In the prime of their careers Manning > Rodgers

This season Rodgers > Manning

They are both so very close though